The lawyer for the owner of Barclay Farm Shopping Center in Cherry Hill contends a 65-year-old deed for the property cannot be considered by the Planning Board in its review of an application to build a Super Wawa on the site.

Neighborhood opponents of the Super Wawa say a provision in the deed and supporting documents from the Barclay farming family to builder Bob Scarborough prohibits oil tanks on the property.

But that's not an issue for the Planning Board, according to Richard J. Goldstein of Hangley, Aronchick, Segal Pudlin & Schiller, representing owner Hortense Associates LP, which is part of Kaiserman Company Inc., a Philadelphia-based real estate company.


The deed from March 7, 1956 prohibits oil tanks on the property in a section forbidding oil and mining operations.

 "These restrictions are, for a variety of reasons, either not applicable to the Shopping Center or, to the extent they might be applicable, not valid or enforceable," Goldstein states in an August 3 letter to the Township Community Development Department. "Furthermore, if any restrictions are applicable and enforceable, our proposed plan will be in compliance."

Goldstein states that any challenge growing from deed restrictions should be "pursuant to a private legal action outside of the jurisdiction of the Planning Board and not relevant to the determinations to be made by the Planning Board."

The Goldstein letter and other amended filings by the developer with the Township were obtained by 70and73.com through an Open Public Records Act request. 

Goldstein also suggests enforcement of any deed restrictions could have a far-reaching impact beyond the Wawa project.

"It should be noted that if any of the deed restrictions are applicable and enforceable, they would apply to all of the residential properties in the vicinity of the Shopping Center covered by the convenants, as well as to all or part of the Shopping Center, and would result in the possibility of imposing a potentially significant and costly burden on each of the residential and commercial properties affected," he states.

A group, Preserve Barclay, has hired a land-use lawyer to formally oppose Kaiserman and Wawa at the board hearings. The application has yet to be scheduled before the Planning Board.


One of the landscaped medians, maintained by residents, that builder Bob Scarborough included as landmarks to the entrances of his Barclay Farm development in the 1960s. The current driveway from the shopping center is to the left. This West Gate Drive median would be eliminated under the Super Wawa plan.

The Wawa would be built at the northwest corner of the center's parking lot and would require the demolition of a pet supplies store — the former Community Theatre — and the Barclay Pavilion office building.

In addition, the owner proposes to demolish a house, used as a professional office, on West Gate Drive to make way for a driveway onto the road and eliminate the landscaped median and sign for the Barclay Farm development. A similar median from Kingston Estates across Route 70 also would be removed under Wawa's changes to the surrounding roads.


Amended plans from the owner of the shopping center show a Barclay Farm neighborhood sign at the intersection of Route 70 and West Gate Drive.

A July 7 letter to the Township from the developer's consultants, Dynamic Engineering Consultants PC of Toms River, notes that the plan now calls for relocating the "neighborhood identification sign" to a corner of the shopping center's lot near Route 70 and West Gate Drive. The final location would be determined during construction after consulting with Township officials, according to the plans.

The center owner also reduced the width of a proposed driveway from the center to West Gate Drive to 25 feet from 28 feet, according to Dynamic Engineering's letter. The house being used as a professional office would be demolished to make way for the driveway. A pedestrian walkway also has been added, connecting West Gate Drive to the Wawa, the consultants told the Township in the letter.

» MORE FROM 70and73:


The Super Wawa would dominate the Barclay Farm Shopping Center lot. The gasoline station section would be built where the former Community Theatre now stands. The Barclay Pavilion office building, bottom left, would be torn down and a second phase to the project calls for a new 12,499-square-foot building with two tenants.


This building opened as a 600-seat Community Theatre in June 1963, entertaining Cherry Hill's growing suburban population with first-run films on its one screen. It would be razed under the plan to build a Super Wawa on the shopping center.