Ann Dollarton, a 2021 Cherry Hill East High School graduate, said she was away at college when she heard the bad news from her mother, a long-time teacher at her alma mater.
"I got a call on April 13 from my mom, and she was in tears," she said of math teacher Susan Nicolazzo-Dollarton, known affectionately as "Miss Nic" to her East students. "She could barely get it out that she had been force-transferred after 20-plus straight years at Cherry Hill East."
Ann Dollarton, other alumni, current Cherry Hill students, parents and teachers showed up at the Cherry Hill Board of Education meeting on Tuesday night seeking an explanation about the reportedly nine East teachers and 16 total teachers who learned — some by email — before the spring break that they would be transferred against their wishes.
"This decision is far past unfair," Dollarton said of her mother's transfer next school year to Cherry Hill West High School.
Many of the teachers have taught for decades in their schools and, in one case, Tom Rosenberg, a highly specialized Advanced Placement history teacher from East, is being transferred to a middle school, where AP courses are not taught. The transfers have set social media, particularly Facebook, afire with sharp criticism of the district administration. Petitions are circulating to get the district to rescind some individual transfers.
"It's tearing apart the district,"Â Rick Short, a resident and frequent district critic, told the board. He likened Cherry Hill teachers to "football quarterback stars" who are legends and stay in one school for years.
Christopher Shin, a junior at East and student body president next fall, said "the district could have been more respectful to the community when making such an important decision."
On Tuesday night, the students and parents sought reasons behind that decision, pleading for more transparency.
They got little.
"There is not a whole lot of detail that I can go into about teacher transfers," said Superintendent Joseph Meloche, who was named to the top role in 2015 and is the first district alumnus to serve as superintendent.
Meloche told the board and protestors that personnel moves cannot be discussed publicly. He said teacher transfer, usually within schools, occurs in Cherry Hill and other districts every year.
"Any staff member that is being transferred or being reassigned within the school district is somebody who has a demonstrated record of success, has been successful with the students, who has demonstrated they can establish and maintain relationships with students and who has positively impacted students and the school community in the work that they have done and what they have provided," Meloche said.
But those who spoke after Meloche's comments demanded a better explanation and urged the district to reconsider the transfers.
"The last two years have been challenging, to say the least," said Devyn Levin, an East senior who is the current student-body president. "Now, the administration has decided to inflict additional hardship by moving nine teachers, many of whom are essential to the East community."
She told the board that many of the transferred teachers have taught at East for decades and are involved with students beyond the classroom, as advisors for clubs and coaches for sports teams.
"The methodology without transparency of a fair and reasonable explanation makes these moves seem punitive," Levin told the board. "The frustration and outrage by both students and parents have been overwhelming. The administration cannot hurt our community like this without explanation."
