Ruts on the sides of McElwee Road in Moorestown show where drivers on the 15-foot-wide road pull to the side to let other vehicles pass.
A plan to use state money to repave and widen a Moorestown Township road is similar to other programs routinely approved every year by South Jersey municipalities.
But the Township's proposal to add 2½ feet to each side of a 15-foot-wide section of McElwee Road near Creek Road has proven to be anything but routine.
"We never thought spending money to improve a road that we saw was crumbling would get us so much passion," Deputy Mayor Sue Mammarella said at this week's Town Council meeting after more than two hours was spent listening to public testimony and a detailed explanation of road-improvement plans.
For the second meeting in a row, the Township postponed a decision and asked its professionals for more research on the road design and potential options other than widening. The issue will be considered again at the April 25 meeting.
» READ MORE: Some Moorestown residents tell town to forget improving road.
McElwee is one of four roads in Moorestown formally designated in the Township's Master Plan as "Scenic Roads." Residents who live along the part to be widened — some of whom have lived there all their lives — told Council that the charm of the bucolic setting would be forever destroyed by the widening.
On the other side at the Monday night meeting, however, were several residents who live in huge, newer homes at the other end of McElwee and the connecting Brandywine Drive. Some of the mini-mansions have about 7,000 to 9,000 square feet of living space, according to real estate records.
They urged Council to approve the widening project because, they said, the section that is too narrow for two cars to pass makes it unsafe and inconvenient. The road in front of the newer homes already is wider.
While the two sides squared off against each other, and their pleas were as passionate as Mammarella said, the overall tone of the meeting was polite and respectful, with some residents from each side acknowledging the concerns of the others.
"This is democracy in action," Council member Quinton Law said after the public testimony.
Law acknowledged the bad shape of the road, the cost to taxpayers to make temporary annual fixes and the safety of bikers and walkers.
But, Law said, "my number one priority when considering this issue is conserving the scenic nature of the street." He urged his fellow Council members to explore more options.
Council member Jake Van Dyken said the project presents Council with a balancing act and a "tough decision."Â
He said the road is in "terrible condition" and "the road is not owned by the residents" because it is a public road. Van Dyken said safety and liability concerns outweigh all others.
Council member David Zipin said that, even with the changes, the road would not be wide. The state Department of Transportation prefers to have 12-foot-wide lanes, and a 24-foot-wide road, according to the Monday night's engineering presentation. McElwee's width would be 20 feet after the project.
He said he was not sure how such a relatively small widening could be a detriment to the scenic nature of the neighborhood.
Some residents disagreed, maintaining a widening would be aesthetically fatal to the views along the country road.
 "It will forever be changed. You can't get it back," Jon Simpson of McElwee Road told Council members.Â
Added Cheryl Lynne Simpson, who said she grew up on McElwee, bought property there when she was married, raised her family there and plans to retire on the road: "It would significantly and forever alter the very fabric of the road. And it would intrinsically change the charm and historic nature of this Moorestown gem."
"Please do not prostitute McElwee Road by widening it," said Trish Radey, whose family has lived on the road for decades.
Doug Maute of Pleasant Valley Avenue, a former chair of the Township Planning Board, said McElwee Road is a "special place."
Maute said he was concerned about the Township engineers' widening plan presented at the meeting. "What I can see on the slides is horrifying," he said.
Other McElwee residents, or those who live nearby, urged Council to widen the road.
"I love the charm of it. I believe that we can retain the charm of it," said Michael Shaw of McElwee Road. He said the road now is "riddled with potholes" and that drivers are forced to drive off the side of the road to accommodate an oncoming car.
McElwee is a "disaster of a road," said David Wojcik, who lives on Brandywine Drive, which connects to McElwee. "It is a very serious safety issue and it is an issue that is faced by bicyclists, pedestrians and drivers every day," Wojcik told Council.
"It is probably one of the worst roads in Moorestown," said Gary Siemons, who also lives on Brandywine Drive. He said he drives the road several times each day.
Dr. Sharmil Gohil said she was adamant against moving to McElwee Road because of the road safety issue, but her family decided to move anyway.
The proposed widening and improvements now are welcome, said Gohil, a Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania anesthesiologist who said she often needs to leave for work at 4:30 in the morning during bad weather conditions.
