A consultant's study being used by Evesham Township Council to restructure management — based largely on a survey and one-hour interviews with leaders of 12 municipal departments — found several key challenges in the government's operations.
The December 2020 study — by Georgia Kay Martin of Collaborative Executive Management Consulting — states that the interviews uncovered four "overarching challenges" that are "offered as recommendations for future improvements to the culture, transparency and accountability of those in leadership roles for the benefit of the Evesham Township taxpayers."
Those four areas are: commitment, morale/culture, limited strategic planning and prioritization. The prioritization challenge, the only one detailed, leads to "lack of discipline in developing and implementing important initiatives," according to the report.
However, additional details of those challenges may be in the 11 pages of the 40-page report that the township fully redacted in the copy of the study emailed to 70and73.com late Tuesday afternoon as a result of the news media organization's Open Public Records Act request.
Council members on February 24 voted unanimously to restructure management of the town-owned Indian Spring Country Club and the Department of Public Works. The changes include adding a deputy township manager for municipal property who would be paid between $95,000 and $120,000 and oversee the town's public works department and open space.
The restructuring eliminated the position of the director of golf, Township Manager Robert Corrales told 70and73.com after the vote. Bob Hennefer, the golf course's PGA director of golf and township open space, resigned the same day the Council voted. The realignment also eliminated the job of superintendent of public works.
Martin recommended in the study that "golf, recreation and open space establish a true strategy for golf and reorganize to ensure parks, rec and open space needs dedicated leadership focus apart (separate) from the golf course."
But the notion of a deputy township manager to lead the public works and municipal property areas was not in the report. Martin did, however, recommend establishing a deputy township manager for personnel, formerly the director of human resources.
Under the management study plan, a township director of parks, recreation and open space would be hired and the golf course would fall under that manager. A day after the vote, Corrales told 70and73.com the golf course managers would report directly to him.
"Reorganization of this area is being recommended to ensure that parks, open space and recreation are the main focus of the strategy to ensure outdoor space in a post-pandemic climate is serving a larger portion of residents than a golf leader," the consultant wrote.
Consultant Martin advised the township to determine an "ongoing strategy" for Indian Spring Country Club. "Today your course is led by a very professional and articulate PGA Professional (Hennefer). Is a PGA course the strategy for the township in the future," she asked.
Martin on Wednesday said in an email to 70and73.com that the study is owned by the township "and I am not at liberty to discuss given the nature and my confidentiality agreement with them."
Evesham did not advertise for bids or proposals for the study last year because the anticipated cost fell under the bid threshold of $17,500, Corrales said on February 25. He said the study cost about $17,000.
» MORE: A bad slice? Evesham Township changes at Indian Spring Country Club irk some golfers.
» MORE: More employee departures disclosed in Evesham Township municipal government.
70and73.com on Wednesday asked Corrales for comment on the management study, but he has not responded.
In her study, Martin said the survey of the township's 12 department heads showed "the majority feel they would garner an 80% satisfaction rate from the residents of the community." But, Martin added: "When further probed, there is no basis for this measurement, ranking or satisfaction rate. We will further probe 'how' they know this."
Martin identifies herself as an "executive management consultant" and lives on Mill Road in the township, according to the study. Her background in the study states: "An experienced leader who has served in the federal government at the senior executive service level and has been repurposing, reorganizing large matrixed organizations for more than 15 years, Kay Martin brings government expertise and the latest cutting-edge commercial solutions to her consultancy work."
A LinkedIn profile for Martin — she confirmed it is her's — shows her as senior vice president for Compass Group USA, a large food and support services company based in Charlotte, North Carolina. Her federal government experience is listed as two years beginning in 2007 as associate director of the U.S. Department of the Interior in Washington D.C., focusing on real estate appraisal and acquisition and disposal.
